Pinoy Idol Episode 10 - Top 24 Results
can I just say that this is offically the worst Idol show ever!!! Actually I dont know if I will still record the show. cos this show is not worth my time. If you dont believe me then watch the show and you will know what I mean. Just a warning though if you dont want to be disappointed dont watch this episode or better yet the whole show.
anyways here are the videos from this very disappointing episode
Part 1
Part 2
Part 3
Part 4
anyways here are the videos from this very disappointing episode
Part 1
Part 2
Part 3
Part 4
At last, idol_fan you commented about Pinoy Idol. Because since last Friday Night's Show, I'm wondering why you are not commenting about the show or other viewers are not commenting about it. I thought I'm only the one who is thinking that GMA 7 murdered the Idol Franchise. I've been a fan of the Idol Franchise for a long time and this is the most disappointing part, I thought that GMA 7 would give justice to the Idol Franchise and do better than ABC 5. But it turned out that ABC 5 handled the Idol Franchise very well and by a comfortable mile better than GMA 7. Even the sound quality of ABC 5 is better. Even the sound quality is not excellent in Philippine Idol, it's enough to satisfy the viewers. In Pinoy Idol, the sound quality is very poor. The band is not that Great compared to Mel Villena's Band. He did a great job as a Musical Director. Mark Reyes did an awesome job in directing Philippine Idol. The camera movements and angels are the same as American Idol considering the fact that the ABC 5's NEWS Department handles the coverage of Philippine Idol due to lack of funds. While in Pinoy Idol, Louie Ignacio ruined the Idol Franchise. The shots and the camera movements and angels are really bad. They cannot match ABC 5's work. GMA 7 doesn't know how to handle the sound effects of the Idol Franchise. The effects were either late and most of the time especially before the commercial break, there is no sound effect. The Judges are useless, they do not teach GMA's Voting Public to vote and be educated. Atleast during ABC 5's Top 24 the judges tried to give relevant comments. GMA is rushing the comments of the judges and sometimes only one judge is commenting. How can that affect the Voters. Ryan Agoncillio is better than Raymond. Ryan knows how to host the Franchise while Raymond doesn't even know how to deliver his lines well and how to handle situations. The set is a copy cat of American Idol. The sad part is that it's like a Pirated Copy made out of "Kartons". Even the judges table is awful. The Idol logo is not great. The audience is is like statues there and it looks like they don't know what's happening. No interaction with the audience. Some of the contestants have no originality and most of them are old fashioned singers. How could this Franchise battle with ABS-CBN's Pinoy Dream Academy? Before Pinoy Idol started, I have a lot of expectations that GMA could make this Big and will match or do better than what ABC 5 did. I'm really disappointed. I hope the Idol Franchise was given to ABC 5 so that they could try it again and hopefully make it big for Season 2. I'm sorry to tell this but I think ABS-CBN's Pinoy Dream Academy will crush Pinoy Idol. They couldn't match the standards of Pinoy Dream Academy considering that they have more talented possible scholars from PDA Primers. And that Maestro Ryan Cayabyab will be the new Head Master together with their Vocal Coaches, The Company and other teachers. With the machinery of ABS-CBN, Star Records, Myx, WRR 101.9 and TFC, the GRAND STAR Dreamer will surely become a GOLD Artist before the end of the show and have a no. 1 hit even he/she is still inside the Academy like Yeng Constatino and eventually be a multi-Platinum Artist. Buti na lang Pinoy Idol yung title ng GMA para hindi madamay si Mau Marcelo sa kababuyang ginawa ng GMA 7 sa Idol Franchise. I really hope Mau would recover her career through the help of Sony-BMG. GMA and magandang gawin niyo para makarecover eh bumuo kayo ng Partnership with ABC 5 para iproduce ang Pinoy Idol kasi sila alam nila ang tamang gagawing kulang nga lang ang mga resources nila pero alam nila. Eh kayo madaming resources hindi naman alam ang gagawin.
ReplyDeletebelieve me we have the same sentiments regarding how they ruined the show. its just that at first I thought that the show will improve but NOO. its even got worse. this I think is the worst episode Ive ever seen in a any idol series. I cant believe they ruined my favorite show in the world. hayy we dont have any choice past is past. I still hope they will do better next week. or else Im really thru with this stupid show.
ReplyDeleteAfter watching the result night.. geez... its a nightmare... what kind of directing is that. they seemed to hurry p on eliminating people and not emphazing what the contestants did... and the host doesn't show any symphaty on the contestants being eliminated. point blunt.... imagine telling it straight forward in his face you out without any comfort...
ReplyDeleteThey stage area is quite satisfactory, but the whole production is a mess... I can't quite feel the vibe. and the judges really sucked. theres not a constructive criticism... not to mention the host is just like memorizing lines... be articulate. think of what the situation must called forth...
OVERALL ranking: DISASTER....
I THINK ITS TOO EARLY for us to judge the show. Im not an idol fanatic,but im rili pro on pinoy talents these peeps does. Ive seen the show i can say that there are some lapses but for sure with the help of your comments this pipol in the industry will for sure do something bout it. But i still believe its not a disaster nor a nightmare
ReplyDeleteThats why we Pinoys are not moving forward coz wer so prejudicial of or own product. With this they have a lot of room to improve and for sure GMA is doing its best to simply give us the best
Its rili early for us to judge the entire show, im excited about the up coming episodes..., =)