Polls
Who do you think has the best version of Bittersweet Symphony?
Australian Idol 5 - Matt Corby - Top 8
Canadian Idol - Kalan Porter - Mod Club
Rockstar Supernova - Lukas Rossi
Australian Idol 5 - Matt Corby - Top 8
Canadian Idol - Kalan Porter - Mod Club
Rockstar Supernova - Lukas Rossi
Lukas. No question about it..
ReplyDeleteLukas rocks it out!
ReplyDeleteI think you should post a better video of bittersweet symphony from Kalan Porter because there are better ones on youtube then that one, you can barely here anything on that video you posted....please have a look for a better one. Kalan does this song to profection
ReplyDeleteLukas by a landslide.
ReplyDeleteThis is a better video of Kalan. He was at Winnipeg for his second show of his 5-day mini-tour.
ReplyDeletehttp://youtube.com/watch?v=3uQet6SQcBo
Kalan's version is by far the most superior one of the three. Equal to the original, the Verve's, if not better.
thanks I will change it now
ReplyDeleteSorry to confuse you but I really disagree that that video is the best. That Winnipeg one is mine, and the minute the rest of the band kicks in, it's just distortion. Dang digital camera!
ReplyDeleteThis one from Edmonton is the absolute best one in existence so far, since you can actually hear the vocals:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ssNTn3YfFqo
lol, sorry everyone is throwing a ton of links at you... you just really need good audio if you're gonna compare to two other videos that have studio sound to them.
Lukas' arrangement is better than the original!
ReplyDeleteAll three bring something different to it, Lukas does "rock it out". But in the end, Kalan's violin, vocals, and emotion get my vote.
ReplyDeleteViolin trumps all!
ReplyDeleteI mean c'mon, that Kalan due was actually PLAYING the F*ing song! How cool is that? Not a bad vocalist either...but the video quality is kinda crappy.
Lukas brings it all, his energy is infectious, my vote goes to him.
ReplyDeleteYeah. What Sarah said. Wish you could put up the Edmonton version as that one's got the best sound so far. Make it a more level playing field so far as the technical aspect goes.
ReplyDeleteSo far as the performance aspect, Kalan hands down. His incredible violin skills and fabulous voice nail this song. It's definitely maximum goosebumps to hear him do it live.
I attempted to listen to all three, but the distortion on Kalan's video really bugged. To be fair I went to the Edmonton youtube post Sarah recommended, and the sound was much better. I'm really glad I did because wow, that kid just blew me away! What a talent! Lukas was my hands-down favourite on Rock Star, but in this comparison Kalan wins my vote.
ReplyDeleteyo sarah the link you gave had this error
ReplyDeleteThe url contained a malformed video id.
can you post the correct link pls. thanks
idol fanatic said: "yo sarah the link you gave had this error
ReplyDeleteThe url contained a malformed video id.
can you post the correct link pls. thanks"
I copied and pasted the link and it worked for me just fine. ???? Really great version of BSS, btw.
URL seems fine to me, and other people have been able to view it. I don't know... can I do html in these comments?
ReplyDeleteTest test... try this link?
Try that... don't know what else to do. But I would really suggest that link because it's just so much better sound for comparison's sake.
^okay. I got it
ReplyDeletethanks for the link sarah.